This website uses technologies such as cookies to provide you a better user experience. To learn more refer to our Privacy Policy .

Top
Toronto Blue Jays Hall of Fame Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (3,586)
2020's (194)
2010's (351)
2000's (1,337)
1990's (1,427)
1980's (259)
1970's (17)
1900's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 3,586
1986 O-Pee-Chee - [Base] #359

Bobby Cox

11 from
$2.78
2008 Upper Deck - UD Game Jersey Series 1 #UD-RH

Roy Halladay

3 from
$4.95
1999 Topps Chrome - All-Etch #AE18

Roy Halladay

8 from
$3.93
2004 Bowman - [Base] - 1st Edition #144

Roy Halladay

$6.29
1999 Oh Henry! Toronto Blue Jays - [Base] #32

Roy Halladay

$6.00
1992 Upper Deck - [Base] #355

Roberto Alomar

43 from
$0.77
1995 Donruss - Dominators #4

Roberto Alomar, Carlos Baerga, Craig Biggio

21 from
$0.99
1991 Upper Deck - [Base] #763

Roberto Alomar

45 from
$0.73
2020 Topps Living Set - Online Exclusive [Base] #362

Fred McGriff #/1,904

$6.29
1996 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Refractor #115

Roberto Alomar

2 from
$17.79
1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #ABCD

Winner ABCD

8 from
$17.79
1989 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #19.52

Kirby Puckett (Rick Sutcliffe 52, Rance Mulliniks 192)

3 from
$5.37
1993 Topps - [Base] #701

Top Prospects - Mike Piazza, Brook Fordyce, Carlos Delgado, Donnie Leshnock

372 from
$0.70
1996 Pinnacle - Starburst - Artist Proof #24

Paul Molitor

$12.04
1990 Score - [Base] #271

Fred McGriff

27 from
$0.78
1990 Fleer - [Base] #89

Fred McGriff

33 from
$0.80
2021 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #252

Roberto Alomar

5 from
$1.32
2017 Topps National Baseball Card Day Stadium Promos - Toronto Blue Jays #TBJ-10

Roy Halladay

$7.44
1995 Pinnacle - Gate Attractions #GA14

Paul Molitor

2 from
$3.98
2007 Topps - Own the Game #OTG25

Roy Halladay

26 from
$1.12
1997 Bowman's Best - [Base] #134

Roy Halladay

20 from
$7.90
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] #501

Keith Shore - Vladimir Guerrero, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (1967 Topps Baseball) [U…

$28.99
1992 Topps - [Base] - Gold Winner #225

Roberto Alomar

8 from
$1.35
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #110

Paul Molitor, John Olerud, Roberto Alomar

6 from
$1.07
1994 Fleer Sunoco/Atlantic Collector's Edition - Gas Station Issue [Base] #1

Roberto Alomar

10 from
$0.80
1993 Pinnacle - [Base] #428

Paul Molitor

6 from
$0.99
1993 Upper Deck - Then & Now #TN9

Dave Winfield

20 from
$1.14
1989 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #62.72

Danny Jackson (Hubie Brooks 72, Fred McGriff 185)

2 from
$1.92
1989 O-Pee-Chee Super Star Sticker Backs - [Base] #9.51

Paul Molitor (Damon Berryhill 51, Kelly Gruber 187)

2 from
$3.53
1989 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #50.52

Tony Gwynn (Rick Sutcliffe 52, Rance Mulliniks 192)

$4.80
2022 Topps Heritage - Then and Now #TAN-RR

Nolan Ryan, Robbie Ray

8 from
$1.39
1989 O-Pee-Chee Super Star Sticker Backs - [Base] #10.205

Tony Fernandez (Robin Yount 205)

3 from
$2.38
1989 O-Pee-Chee Super Star Sticker Backs - [Base] #10.16

Tony Fernandez (Bill Doran 16; Jim Rice 256)

3 from
$2.38
1988 Sportflics - [Base] #168

Fred McGriff [Poor to Fair]

$2.55
1994 Post Collection - [Base] #18

Roberto Alomar [EX to NM]

2 from
$2.83
2020 Topps Stadium Club Chrome - [Base] - X-Fractor #153

Roberto Alomar

2 from
$5.72
1991 Score - [Base] #404

Fred McGriff [EX to NM]

2 from
$3.13
1993 Continental Baking Hostess Baseballs - [Base] #14

Roberto Alomar [Poor to Fair]

$1.98
1993 Topps - [Base] #131

Dave Winfield

56 from
$0.75
1985 Toronto Star/Midas Toronto Blue Jays Ontario Fire Chiefs Fire Safety - [Base] #6

Bobby Cox

$14.34
2006 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Refractor #207

Roy Halladay

3 from
$5.99
1987 Topps Traded - [Base] #74T

Fred McGriff

43 from
$1.85
1994 Flair - Hot Numbers #5

Paul Molitor

8 from
$1.52
1990 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #35.11

Fred McGriff (Tony Fernandez 11, Jerome Walton 327)

$4.84
2005 Upper Deck Hall of Fame - Cooperstown Calling - Silver Autographs #CO-PM2

Paul Molitor #/10

$89.06
2004 Playoff Prestige - Players Collection Relics #PC-82

Roy Halladay

$10.89
1994 Oh Henry! Toronto Blue Jays - [Base] #12

Roberto Alomar

2 from
$3.99
1989 Fleer - Box Bottoms - Gray Back #C-19

Fred McGriff

$9.74
1993 Topps - [Base] #50

Roberto Alomar

36 from
$0.85
1993 Topps - [Base] - Gold #50

Roberto Alomar

25 from
$0.75
1991 Donruss - [Base] #261.1

Fred McGriff (Right Border has 2 Designs) [EX to NM]

$3.13
2004 Upper Deck Reflections - [Base] #211

Roy Halladay

3 from
$7.44
2004 Fleer Tradition - Diamond Tributes - Jersey #DT-RH

Roy Halladay

4 from
$4.87
2007 Fleer Ultra - Strike Zone - Materials #SZ-RH

Roy Halladay

5 from
$6.29
2008 SPx - Winning Materials - Jersey Number #WM-RH

Roy Halladay #/125

2 from
$11.47
2008 Topps Updates & Highlights - All-Star Stitches #AS-RH

Roy Halladay

2 from
$7.44
1993 Donruss - The Elite Series #35

Dave Winfield #/10,000

4 from
$16.64
1994 Score Select - Most Valuable Player #MVP1

Paul Molitor

$5.14
1986 Leaf Canadian - [Base] #28

Rated Rookies - Fred McGriff

33 from
$4.20
1987 Topps Traded - [Base] - Tiffany #74T

Fred McGriff

17 from
$8.58
1995 SP - Special FX #26

Paul Molitor

2 from
$2.83
1995 Pinnacle - Red Hot #RH23

Roberto Alomar

8 from
$1.40
1989 O-Pee-Chee Super Star Sticker Backs - [Base] #20.194

Dave Winfield (Dave Stieb 194)

$3.53
1977 Topps - [Base] #473

Rookie Outfielders - Andre Dawson, Gene Richards, John Scott, Denny Walling

7 from
$14.04
1995 Upper Deck Collector's Choice - [Base] #145

Paul Molitor

7 from
$0.80
1993 Donruss McDonald's Toronto Blue Jays Great Moments - Restaurant [Base] #15

Old Friends

2 from
$1.69
1993 Studio - [Base] #172

Paul Molitor

16 from
$1.07
2022 Topps Heritage - Then and Now #TAN-JG

Reggie Jackson, Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

7 from
$2.27
2008 Upper Deck A Piece of History - Cut from the Same Cloth - Pewter #CSC-PH

Roy Halladay, Jake Peavy #/75

$9.44
1994 Fleer Ultra - All-Star Team #3

Roberto Alomar

22 from
$0.92
1991 Score 100 Hottest Players - Box Set [Base] #71

Fred McGriff

2 from
$1.19
1999 Pacific Omega - [Base] #250

Roy Halladay, Billy Koch

2 from
$2.37
2023 Panini Select - [Base] - Silver Prizm #5

Concourse - Roberto Alomar

2 from
$5.95
1993 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Members Only #142

Roberto Alomar

6 from
$1.36
2023 Panini Select - [Base] - Silver Prizm #66

Concourse - Pat Gillick

2 from
$1.40
2023 Panini Select - [Base] - Tri-Color Prizm #66

Concourse - Pat Gillick

2 from
$2.88
1995 Studio - [Base] - Gold Plastic Stock #10

Paul Molitor

6 from
$1.36
1993 Topps - [Base] #529

Top Prospects - Dave Silvestri, Chipper Jones, Benji Gil, Jeff Patzke

322 from
$0.77
1993 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Members Only #206

Dave Winfield

7 from
$1.21
2009 Topps Unique - Button #UB-RH

Roy Halladay #/6

$175.28
1984 Toronto Blue Jays Fire Safety - [Base] #6

Bobby Cox

2 from
$5.71
1994 Donruss - 90's Dominators Batting Average #3

Paul Molitor

28 from
$0.78
1993 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #206

Dave Winfield

8 from
$0.80
1989 O-Pee-Chee Super Star Sticker Backs - [Base] #10.304

Tony Fernandez (Harold Baines 304)

$2.55
1994 Topps - Black Gold Redemptions #A.1

Winner A (Mail Away Information)

4 from
$4.85
1994 Topps - Black Gold #13

Paul Molitor

8 from
$1.01
2012 Topps Tribute - World Series Swatches - Red #WSS-PM

Paul Molitor [CGC 8.5 NM/Mint+] #/10

$35.90
2007 SP Rookie Edition - [Base] #100

Frank Thomas [CGC 9.5 Mint+]

$23.24
1994 Topps - [Base] - Gold #248

Rickey Henderson

12 from
$1.68
2022 Topps Allen & Ginter X - [Base] #137

Paul Molitor

4 from
$1.11
2005 Bowman - [Base] #31

Roy Halladay [EX to NM]

$1.85
2007 Fleer Ultra - Hitting Machine #HM-FT

Frank Thomas

$3.99
1996 Leaf - [Base] - Silver #80

Paul Molitor

3 from
$1.68
2021 Topps - 1986 Topps All-Star Baseball Relics - Black #86ASRRAL

Roberto Alomar #/199

3 from
$7.15
2005 Donruss Zenith - [Base] - Museum Collection #134

Roy Halladay

$5.99
2003 Upper Deck 40 Man - [Base] - Rainbow #62

Roy Halladay #/40

$86.49
2021 Topps Archives - Movie Poster Cards #MPC-13

Dante Bichette, Bo Bichette, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Vladimir Guerrero Sr., Crai…

6 from
$2.27
2021 Topps - 1986 Topps All-Star Baseball #86AS47

Roberto Alomar

9 from
$1.07
1993 Donruss - MVPs #MVP-6

Roberto Alomar [BAS BGS Authentic]

$70.40
1994 Sportflics 2000 - [Base] #31

Roberto Alomar

10 from
$1.06
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 36