This website uses technologies such as cookies to provide you a better user experience. To learn more refer to our Privacy Policy .

Top
Pre-Rookie Card Hall of Fame Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (2,689)
2020's (192)
2010's (504)
2000's (228)
1990's (515)
1980's (692)
1970's (230)
1960's (85)
1950's (58)
1940's (108)
1930's (18)
1920's (8)
1910's (11)
1900's (39)
1880's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 2,689
1941 Double Play - R330 #33-34

Lee Handley, Arky Vaughan [Poor to Fair]

$31.53
2005 Upper Deck Hall of Fame - [Base] #10

Buck Leonard #/550

2 from
$11.75
2013 Panini Cooperstown Collection - [Base] - Gold Crystal Shard #28

Buck Leonard #/299

$28.99
1996 Best Dunedin Blue Jays - [Base] #12

Roy Halladay

$29.29
1992 Upper Deck Minor League - [Base] #82

Tony Tarasco, Chipper Jones

$3.42
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #24

Max Carey

2 from
$2.44
1991 Classic Best Minor League - [Base] #355

Pedro Martinez

37 from
$1.16
1990 Classic Draft Picks - Box Set [Base] #1

Chipper Jones

30 from
$2.15
1990 Classic Draft Picks - Box Set [Base] #20

Mike Mussina

35 from
$1.06
1988 Pacific Eight Men Out - [Base] #41

Edd Roush

5 from
$1.84
1986 Kool-Aid Houston Astros Police - [Base] #26

Coaching Staff (Gene Tenace, Matt Galante, Denis Menke, Yogi Berra, Les Moss)

3 from
$19.17
1986 Fleer - Team Stickers Inserts/Baseball's Famous Feats #_PIPI.1

Pittsburgh Pirates Pennant - Deacon Phillippe

5 from
$1.20
1992 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #342

Rube Marquard [Poor to Fair]

$6.00
1983 TCMA All-Time St. Louis Cardinals - [Base] - White Back #6

Chick Hafey

$6.29
2001 Topps Chrome - What Could Have Been #WCB8

Mule Suttles

$16.64
1991 Classic Update Green Travel Edition - [Base] #T55

Pedro Martinez [BGS 8.5 NM‑MT+]

$23.24
1988 Pittsburgh Pirates Negro League Stars Team Issue - [Base] #14

Cool Papa Bell

$29.29
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Green Ice Prizm #293

Buck Leonard

$4.28
1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - [Base] #48

Ban Johnson

32 from
$1.80
1992-93 Topps Stadium Club Jack Murphy Stadium - Box Set [Base] #117

Derek Jeter

8 from
$92.24
1994 Ted Williams Card Company - [Base] #106

Bud Fowler

9 from
$14.04
1990 ProCards A & AA Minor League Stars - [Base] #26

Jeff Bagwell

13 from
$1.51
1947-66 Exhibits - W461 #_RIAS.2

Richie Ashburn (Philadelphia Phillies; Name Spelled Ritchie)

3 from
$11.74
1947-66 Exhibits - W461 #_GEKE

George Kell

2 from
$8.29
1992 Classic Best Minor League - [Base] #402

Derek Jeter

11 from
$5.43
2008 Upper Deck - Multi-Product Insert Yankee Stadium Legacy #YSL732

Joe McCarthy

2 from
$2.50
2023 Panini Select - [Base] - Silver Prizm #66

Concourse - Pat Gillick

2 from
$1.40
2023 Panini Select - [Base] - Tri-Color Prizm #66

Concourse - Pat Gillick

2 from
$2.88
1973 Topps - [Base] #205

1972 World Series - Reds Win Squeeker

35 from
$0.96
1992 Front Row Draft Picks - Promos #_DEJE

Derek Jeter

9 from
$15.69
1992 Front Row Draft Picks - [Base] - Gold #55

Derek Jeter

3 from
$83.14
2013 Panini Cooperstown Collection - Numbers Game #4

Addie Joss, Ed Walsh

2 from
$3.42
1982 Renata Galasso 20 Years of New York Mets Baseball - [Base] #32

George Weiss

$9.17
1990 Classic Update Yellow Travel Edition - [Base] #T91

Nolan Ryan, Reid Ryan

26 from
$0.85
2008 Upper Deck - Multi-Product Insert Yankee Stadium Legacy #YSL749

Joe McCarthy

3 from
$3.42
2008 Upper Deck - Multi-Product Insert Yankee Stadium Legacy #YSL949

Joe McCarthy

2 from
$6.29
2023 Panini Three and Two - [Base] - Bases Loaded #29

Buck Leonard #/3

$34.74
1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - [Base] #126

Joe McGinnity [Good to VG‑EX]

$6.56
1990 Classic Update Yellow Travel Edition - [Base] #T92

Chipper Jones

14 from
$3.36
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #17

James "Cool Papa" Bell #/500

$16.35
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #18

James "Cool Papa" Bell #/500

$16.35
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #16

James "Cool Papa" Bell #/500

$16.35
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #15

James "Cool Papa" Bell #/500

$16.35
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #14

James "Cool Papa" Bell #/500

$16.35
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #13

James "Cool Papa" Bell #/500

$16.35
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #12

James "Cool Papa" Bell #/500

$16.35
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #11

James "Cool Papa" Bell

$16.35
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #10

Rube Foster

$12.90
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #09

Rube Foster

$12.90
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #08

Rube Foster

$12.90
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #07

Rube Foster

$12.90
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #06

Rube Foster

$11.75
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #05

Rube Foster

$12.90
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #04

Rube Foster [EX to NM]

$12.90
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #03

Rube Foster [EX to NM]

$12.90
2020 Dreams Fulfilled Negro Leagues Mount Rushmore Postcards - [Base] #02

Rube Foster [EX to NM]

$12.90
1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - [Base] #12

Max Carey [Good to VG‑EX]

12 from
$1.90
2013 Panini Cooperstown Collection - Numbers Game #18

Jake Beckley

$2.26
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #33

Chick Hafey

5 from
$1.06
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #34

Bill McKechnie

3 from
$3.00
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #138

75 Years Ago World Champs - Rube Foster

5 from
$1.09
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #259

All Time Leader - Chick Hafey

6 from
$0.84
2008 SP Legendary Cuts - Headliners & Heroes Cut Signatures #HH-MC

Max Carey #/31

$115.24
2021 Panini National Treasures - Cut Signature Material Booklets - City #CSMB-MX

Max Carey #/5

$104.10
1921 Exhibits - [Base] #_REFA

Red Faber

$87.01
1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - [Base] #39

Chick Hafey

17 from
$2.09
1988 Fleer Update - [Base] #U-74

John Smoltz [PSA 7 NM]

$23.25
2000 Upper Deck MVP - Draw Your Own Card #DT9

Mickey Mantle (Drawn by Kat Rhyne)

24 from
$1.81
1987 ProCards Minor League - [Base] #372

John Smoltz [SGC 10 GEM]

$274.00
1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - [Base] #7

Dave Bancroft [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from
$2.73
1988 Score Rookies & Traded - Factory Set [Base] #103T

Craig Biggio

16 from
$5.83
1979 Topps - [Base] #418

All-Time Record Holders - Dutch Leonard, Walter Johnson (Earned Run AVG)

190 from
$0.85
1995 Bowman's Best - Mirror Image - Refractor #1

Ben Davis, Ivan Rodriguez

15 from
$1.23
2013 Panini Cooperstown Collection - Numbers Game #8

Billy Hamilton

3 from
$2.99
2013 Panini Cooperstown Collection - International Play #10

Cristobal Torriente

2 from
$15.16
1987 TCMA/CMC International League All-Stars/Future Stars - [Base] #1987-32

Tom Glavine [PSA 9 MINT]

$52.00
1991 Upper Deck Final Edition - Box Set [Base] #2F

Pedro Martinez

88 from
$2.26
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #60

George Kelly

4 from
$1.61
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #252

All Time Leader - Rube Marquard

9 from
$0.84
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #272

All Time Leader - Addie Joss

6 from
$1.28
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #28

Joe McCarthy

3 from
$1.81
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #135

75 Years Ago World Champs - Harry Hooper

5 from
$1.06
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #17

Dave Bancroft

5 from
$1.09
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #26

Ross Youngs

5 from
$1.58
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #55

Edd Roush

7 from
$0.99
1988 Fleer Update - [Base] #U-74

John Smoltz

54 from
$1.50
1988 Fleer Update - [Base] #U-89

Craig Biggio

82 from
$1.53
2021 Panini Immaculate Collection - Legends Materials #LG-16

Tom Yawkey #/49

$58.04
2014 Panini Hall of Fame - Blue Shield - Red #38

Dave Bancroft #/50

2 from
$14.34
1992 Classic Best Minor League - Bonus Card - Blue #BC22

Derek Jeter [Good to VG‑EX]

6 from
$2.12
1992-93 Fleer Excel - [Base] #210

Derek Jeter

29 from
$5.77
2012 Panini Cooperstown - Museum Pieces #6

Buck Leonard

8 from
$2.78
2012 Panini Cooperstown - Hall History #7

Effa Manley

3 from
$14.18
2012 Panini Cooperstown - [Base] #162

Jesse Burkett

2 from
$9.34
2012 Panini Cooperstown - [Base] #129

Sam Thompson

4 from
$2.26
2012 Panini Cooperstown - [Base] #105

Addie Joss

9 from
$2.99
2012 Panini Cooperstown - [Base] #38

Tommy McCarthy

2 from
$19.84
1990 Southern League All-Stars - [Base] #46

Frank Thomas, Jeff Conine

5 from
$3.91
2023 Panini Chronicles - Pinnacle #20

Cool Papa Bell

4 from
$2.50
2016 Bowman - Family Tree - Orange #FT-R

Mariano Rivera, Mariano Rivera #/25

$49.42
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 27